Please turn off your ad blocker to properly view this site. Thank you!
Protecting Our Food, Farms & Environment
toggle menu
Pacific Northwest
Hawai'i CFS

Emergency Lawsuit Filed in Oregon GE Labeling Recount

December 08, 2014
Center for Food Safety

“Count Every Vote” Demands Right to Know Campaign

Portland, Oregon (December 8, 2014) – Today, Oregon citizens whose votes were not counted filed a lawsuit in the Circuit Court of the State of Oregon to ensure that their votes and those of approximately 4,600 others are not unfairly rejected. Oregon is currently undergoing a mandatory statewide hand recount of Measure 92, the genetically engineered (GE) food labeling initiative. With more than 1.5 million votes cast, the difference was less than a tenth of a percentage point (812 votes). The lawsuit, also brought by the Oregon Right to Know Campaign, asks the Court to direct the Secretary of State to count 4,600 ballots currently rejected without evidence of fraud or forgery.

“These voters completed their ballots, signed their return identification envelops pursuant to instructions provided by the Secretary of the State and local election officials, and timely returned their ballots. However, local election officials … have not counted these ballots because the voters’ signatures on their return identification envelops do not ‘match’ their signature on file for those voters,” the lawsuit states.

Oregon is a vote by mail state, and voters must sign their ballots; that signature is then compared to a signature on file. Instructions did not inform the voters that their signature must “match” the signature on file, and that requirement is not required Oregon’s election law. There is no evidence that any of these voters have engaged in fraud. Many of these people’s signatures have been altered due to illnesses or disability. Some never received notification that their signature – and their vote – is being challenged. Others tried to correct their signature mismatch with elections officials but still find their vote is not being counted.

“The right to vote is a fundamental right. Thousands of voters should not have their rights denied because of a technicality that the law does not require,” said George Kimbrell, senior attorney with Center for Food Safety. “Absent evidence of forgery or fraud, these ballots must be counted. It’s especially critical here, since the closest statewide election in Oregon history hangs in the balance.”

Center for Food Safety, lead author of Measure 92, supported the Oregon campaign extensively, at the legal, advocacy, and grassroots level and as a member of the Steering Committee. CFS’s political arm, Center for Food Safety Action Fund, raised over $1 million to support Measure 92 and helped mobilize thousands of volunteers in Oregon and across the country. CFS previously worked with and provided legal and grassroots support to campaigns in Oregon to ban the planting of GE crops in two Oregon counties, and worked with the State Senate to ban GE canola in the Willamette Valley until 2019. CFS also co-authored GE food labeling ballot initiatives in California and Washington and has spearheaded nationwide efforts on the issue for over a fifteen years.

Oregon would be the fourth U.S. state to require GE labeling. Connecticut and Maine each passed GE labeling laws this past spring, but both bills include a trigger clause requiring several other states to also pass labeling bills before the new laws can be implemented. Vermont was the first state to pass a no-strings-attached labeling law, set to go into effect in 2016.

Related News